Ryan Feaster

Realtor®
License#: FA100093578
Bannerimage

Why the Best Deal of 2025 Was the One We Walked Away From

By Ryan Feaster - January 22, 2026
The Best Deal I Closed Last Year Started With Walking Away.
I could have let my client buy that house. The commission would have been the same. But my job isn't to get you to closing—it's to get you to the right closing.
Schedule a Strategy Call

Your Agent Should Inform, Empower, and Guide—Not Just Sell.

Most people think a real estate agent's job is to help you buy a house. My job is to help you avoid buying the wrong house.

As your Fiduciary, my primary role is to guide you toward a sound investment—even if that means advising you to walk away. Last year, I worked with a buyer on a home that checked every box on his wish list. The price was right. The location was perfect. But once we started our due diligence, red flags started appearing.

What looked like a $425,000 home was actually a $445,000 problem waiting to happen.

The Discovery: Hidden Defects

During our inspection period, the general inspection uncovered a serious issue with the roof. From the street, it looked fine—relatively new, well-maintained. But the inspector's report revealed something the seller conveniently hadn't mentioned: the shingles were defective, subject to a manufacturer recall, and the warranty claim had already been filed and denied.

Comparison: Beautiful exterior vs hidden structural damage
The "Money Pit" Reality: Beautiful on the outside, costly on the inside.

An agent focused only on closing the deal might have glossed over this. They might have accepted vague assurances from the seller to "look into it" or suggested we "address it after closing." But as a Real Estate Agent who takes my fiduciary responsibility seriously, I couldn't let my client walk into a trap.

The Investigation: Digging Deeper

My client and I didn't accept surface-level answers. We spent hours on the phone with the manufacturer, reviewed the warranty fine print, and consulted with two roofing contractors. Every conversation pointed to the same conclusion: the seller knew about this problem and was hoping to pass the liability onto the next owner.

The Reality: If my client took possession, he'd be inheriting a failing roof with no recourse—potentially costing him $20,000 within his first year of ownership. The "deal" wasn't a deal at all.

This is where my network became invaluable. Most buyers don't have structural engineers, specialized inspectors, or reliable roofing contractors on speed dial. I do. Whether you need a second opinion on foundation concerns or guidance on vetting a contractor for future renovations, I provide a vetted list of professionals you can interview to make informed decisions.

The Decision: Walking Away Cleanly

We decided to walk away. But walking away requires skill, too.

Because I understand the Colorado Contract to Buy and Sell inside and out, we were able to exit the deal cleanly during our inspection objection period. I ensured my client got every penny of his Earnest Money back. His only cost was the inspection fee—a small price to pay to avoid a five-figure mistake.

More importantly, he still had his full buying power intact to find the right home.

What Should a Quality Home Inspection Include?

Ultimately, who you hire is your decision. However, I always advise my clients to choose an inspector who tests beyond the basics. Here in the Denver area, I've seen too many buyers learn expensive lessons because their inspector missed critical issues. Here are the essential checks I look for in a quality report:

Latent Defects: Hidden water intrusion & foundation shifts.
Safety Hazards: Radon gas, trip hazards, & electrical panels.
System Health: Water pressure & hot water temp.
Functionality: Testing every kitchen appliance & HVAC system.

The Better Outcome

Three weeks after walking away from that defective-roof property, my client called with good news. We'd found another home in his target neighborhood—and this one had been meticulously maintained.

This new home was superior in every measurable way: a newer roof with a fully transferable warranty, updated mechanicals with service records, and an owner who'd clearly taken pride in the property. The inspection came back clean. He didn't just dodge a bullet; he upgraded his investment and gained peace of mind.

That better outcome only happened because we were willing to say "No" to the wrong deal.

Key Lessons From This Experience

💡 Never rush due diligence, even in a competitive market. The pressure to act fast can cost you far more than a missed opportunity.

💡 A good agent's network is as valuable as their negotiation skills. Access to trusted professionals can uncover problems before they become your problems.

💡 Walking away is sometimes the smartest move you can make. Protecting your capital today means you're positioned for a better opportunity tomorrow.

Need an Agent Who Will Tell You "No"?

If you want a partner who represents your best interests—not just the fastest path to closing—let's talk. I'll help you make informed decisions, avoid costly mistakes, and find the right investment for your future.

Start the Conversation

Similar Interesting Articles



No Blogs found.

{{Title}}

{{PublishDateString}}

READ MORE
Next

Realty ONE Group, Inc is powered by Burrow Services, Inc.